Are ColourPop Supernova Liquid Shadow Worth the Hype?

It’s been quite a few weeks since I received the ColourPop Supernova shadows and I have been trying to add them into every look I’ve done since then to form a complete opinion on them.  I initially avoided them when they were first launched as it didn’t seem like something I would be interested in since I had already gotten the Stila Magnificent Metals Glitter & Glow Liquid Eyeshadows… but I am allergic to it or something as my eyes just itch like crazy when I wear them. So I thought I would try these to see if the same thing would happen.

I do not have all of the shadows at the moment as the newest ones released were out of stock but I will be getting them when they come back in stock. So the shadows I did manage to get my hands on were: Firecracker, Dragon, Hard to Empress, Moon Lit, Mothership, UF-Woah, Running in Orbits, and Walk of Fame. I still want to get: Over Again, From the Valley, Prelude, Lucky Penny, and Now or Never. Some of these shadows I would honestly would’ve switched their names around if I was ColourPop. Such as Dragon is not the green shade and Lucky Penny is not a copper tone. It just seems so silly, but again it was not my call. I do like the shades are pretty regardless.

ColourPop’s Claim on the Supernova Shadows

These high-impact ultra-glittery shadows have a metallic base, are extremely long-wearing, and can be used as a base, alone, or as a topper.

And I have tried it in every version: base, alone, and topper. I found the best results when I wore them as a base or topper. And the absolute worst when wearing them alone as I found they flaked away and creased throughout the day when worn this way.

ColourPop Supernova Shadows

Shade Descriptions

This includes all of the shadows that have come out though I don’t have them all yet:

  • Firecracker – cool-toned burgundy with gold duochrome and silver, gold, and green glitter
  • Dragon – bright copper with pink, teal, silver, and gold glitter
  • Hard to Empress – warm red with gold duochrome and silver, gold, and copper glitter
  • Moon Lit – vibrant purple with pink, turquoise, and violet glitter
  • Mothership – blackened teal with silver glitter
  • UF-Woah – icy rose with blue glitter
  • Running in Orbits – warm taupe with blue glitter
  • Walk of Fame true gold sprinkled with silver glitter
  • Over Again – hot pink with a violet/blue flip
  • From the Valley – lavender with a pink/blue flip
  • Prelude – peach with a pink/blue flip
  • Lucky Penny – silver with a teal flip
  • Now or Never – silvery taupe with gold/silver flip


Typically I don’t do arm swatches as they aren’t accurate do to the nature of the product, but in this instance that is exactly how they’ll look since you apply them directly to your lids with literally no blending. You might put other shadows over top of them, but that doesn’t change the overall look of the shadow. Hence arm swatches of all of the shadows that I do have.

Supernova Shadows as Topper

Supernova Shadows as a Topper

For this I used the shade Twilight from the My Little Pony Palette as a base for Mothership and Skydancer from My Little Pony Palette as a base for Moonlit. As for all of the others, I used the shade Bitter Better from the I Think I Love You Palette as a base for the rest of the shadows. Was it the best match? No, but this is more just to show how they sit on top of other shadows. The shadows in order over the shadow Bitter Better were: Running in Orbits, UF-Woah, Hard to Empress, Walk of Fame, Firecracker, and Dragon. Walk of Fame and Mothership don’t sit the best on top of other shadows but the rest work beautifully. If I were to do this on the lids, I would probably do the pairings from the Supernova Shadows as Base section as they match up the best with the shadows.

Supernova Shadows Alone

Supernova Shadows Alone

In this grouping, I just swatched all of the shadows on their own. Some of them like Mothership, Moonlit, and Dragon are a little streaky when used on their own. But if you use these with other shadows this is easy to blend out and hide. Swatches in order: Mothership, Moonlit, Dragon, Firecracker, Walk of Fame, UF-Woah, Hard to Empress, and Running in Orbits. Though they might look fine on their own, I do find they crease and flake off if they aren’t set or have a shadow underneath. If you do either of those, then I didn’t see that issue.

Supernova Shadows as Base
Supernova Shadows as a Base

After I did the swatches alone I tried to find similar shadows from the pressed powder shadow palettes also from ColourPop to make the shadows pop. I feel like this is the best way to wear the Supernova shadows as well as bring out the pigments you place on top. So the order is the same but going over what I placed on top from left to right: Twilight from My Little Pony Palette, Skydancer from My Little Pony Palette, Blossom from My Little Pony Palette, Level Up from I Think I Love You Palette, Girls Bite from I Think I Love You Palette, Howdy from I Think I Love You Palette, Bel Air from I Think I Love You Palette, and My Type from I Think I Love You Palette.

Final Thoughts

I seriously love these Supernova Shadows especially when used as a base. I think they really bring out the pressed eyeshadows, even though the shades are wonderful on their own. The Supernova Shadows just bring another level to them and give them that perfect pop. I have been using these shadows every weekend when I do my more full glam look and I have already put in an order for three of the shades I don’t have. Two were still out of stock but if they ever come back they will be quickly be coming my way as I can honestly see myself using these all of the time. If you’ve tried these shadows before, what did you think of them? If not, what’s your opinion on liquid or cream eyeshadows?

Love ya,

Mae Polzine

Join the Howl of the Pack today by subscribing! Or support this blog over on Patreon so I can continue to put out quality content for you! To stay updated on everything I’m doing, follow me on Twitter as that’s where I post quick updates. Also, if you like this post, let me know in the comment section, it really helps me figure out what content you guys appreciate. Don’t be shy I would love to hear from you!


  1. March 28, 2018 / 5:20 AM

    I have all of them as well and keep reaching for them which I will always take as a true indicator on how I feel about a product. Completely agree on the flaking. Mine are everywhere by the end of the day, and yet I still reach for them because I love how they look. I never thought about using them as a base so I will try that next! I also made mention of how weirdly off the shade names seemed… I made mention in my unboxing video about it

    • Mae Polzine
      March 28, 2018 / 6:57 AM

      It just seems so odd that lucky penny wouldn’t be the color of a penny. But yeah, totally try them as a base I see less flaking with that. I mean unless you’re rubbing your eye then it will flake.
      ♥ Mae

      • March 28, 2018 / 7:49 AM

        I literally said the exact same thing about lucky penny ” But this isn’t penny coloured so thats stupid” lol (I’m a bit abrupt in my videos)

      • Mae Polzine
        March 28, 2018 / 8:09 AM

        Lol. I need to watch your video. What’s your channel name?
        ♥ Mae

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this:
Close Me
Looking for Something?
Post Categories: